eibanner (73k image)

 

Home » Archives » September 2004 » Picture, say, Frank Griswold doin' the Time Warp

[Previous entry: "The amazing expanding right to kill"] [Next entry: "Report: Syria used WMDs in Sudan"]

09/13/2004: "Picture, say, Frank Griswold doin' the Time Warp"


Ian Bradley, professor of practical theology at St. Andrews University in Scotland, has written a book in which he advocates the use of musical theater songs in church:

Churches have a great deal to learn from modern musicals and could usefully incorporate in their services the spiritual themes and the pastoral care they offer their audiences, a new book argues.

Startlingly, the thesis–said to be the first to take the theology of musicals seriously–is the product not of a showbusiness hack but a Church of Scotland minister and reader in practical theology at St Andrews University.

Ian Bradley argues in the book
You've Got to Have a Dream, to be published next month, that musicals like Les Misérables and The Rocky Horror Show, not to mention more likely candidates such as The Sound of Music and Jesus Christ Superstar, now form a more common means for people to gain their philosophy of life and spiritual and theological perspectives than attending church.

The Beeb thinks highly of The Sound of Music, so why shouldn't the church?

In the cold war, seeking something to reassure the public in the event of a nuclear attack, the BBC lined up The Sound of Music as the first film that would be broadcast after the bomb dropped, the book says.

And that, I'm sure, would have been very comforting to the survivalists whose television electronics were lead-shielded against electromagnetic pulse. But maybe The Wizard of Oz is more your speed:

The musical version of the Wizard of Oz, filmed in the late 1930s as the US emerged from the depression, has in the words of one commentator, the clear message: "Believe in yourself, stick by your friends, fight for what's right and things will get better."

"Believe in yourself"–yes, I can see why you'd want to use that in a C of E service, what with God being so passé in many Anglican parishes.

The author admits: "I have myself sung from The Sound of Music while preaching in an Anglican cathedral, and from Les Misérables, Godspell and Whistle Down the Wind in school chapels. We could and should be using show songs much more...as worship songs in their own right as well as triggers for prayer, sermons and reflection."

Of course, Bradley doesn't say exactly what you'd be worshipping if you used, say, "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" from Mary Poppins, or "Luck Be a Lady Tonight" from Guys and Dolls, or perhaps "Sweet Transvestite" from The Rocky Horror Show. But I reckon we can use our imaginations.

Replies: 5 Comments

on Tuesday, September 14th, Bill Zapcic said

Andrea and I have been splitting our worship activities between two parishes, one of which is led by a priest heavily into music and notably into chant. I actually find him annoying on the subject, only because he seems to want to drag the parishioners kicking and screaming into agreeing with his point of view. He makes one great point, however: Citing Thomas Day's "Why Catholics Can't Sing" http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0824511530/qid=1095182829/sr=ka-1/ref=pd_ka_1/104-0566689-1767117 he points out that so much of what passes for church music is coopted drinking songs. Such were intended to showcase how polluted the singer was, not how talented.

on Tuesday, September 14th, Andrea Zapcic said

Amazing how two people, married more than twenty years, can listen to the same sermon and hear two entirely different things. Where I diverge, and although I haven't finished the book yet (in truth,I've barely started) is that I feel Catholics shot themselves in the footpedal several years back by forcing the congregation to sing nearly all of the prayers that were once recited as a group. (Talk about annoying!) I further feel that approached correctly, group recititation, a precursor to chant, can be powerful and moving. Turning them into songs seemed to make the collective neurosis about singing in public bubble to the top. However he might like, one priest in one small parish in NJ is not going to turn this tide, so what's the harm in chanting the Our Father as well? As for me, I'll take Stephen Schwartz any day: Prepare Ye and Long Live God!

on Tuesday, September 14th, Athanasius said

Now, now, folks. This isn't the place for intra-household squabble. :rolleyes: I had no idea y'all real my humble blog. I'm honored! I'll have to give you a call this weekend and pursue the discussion in person, but by all means continue the thread here as well. BTW, I loved Day's book.

on Wednesday, September 15th, Michael Ware said

Great idea with the show tunes! The first one could be "I'm Gonna Wash That Man Right Out Of My Hair". We could dedicate to Frank Griswold.

on Wednesday, September 15th, Athanasius said

Well done, Michael!

Home
Archives


"Great blog...and I love the title." Father Hans Jacobse, OrthodoxyToday

"This is a top quality site." Blandus Rex, Ockhamist.com

"Wisdom for the ages...Thomas Aquinas could learn from this guy." Glenn Reynolds

  • E-mail Me!




  • Blogroll Me!

    News Links
    Christianity Today
    First Things
    Touchstone
    Armavirumque: The New Criterion
    GetReligion
    The Weekly Standard
    NRO
    Jerusalem Post
    New York Times
    Washington Post

    Anglican/Protestant Links
    Classical Anglican Net News
    Institute on Religion and Democracy
    Midwest Conservative Journal
    Titusonenine
    Pontifications
    RatherNot Blog
    Stand Firm
    Whirlwind
    Imago Dei
    Blithering Idiot
    Wanderings of a Post-Modern Pilgrim
    Dunker Journal
    Evangelical Outpost
    Martin Roth Christian Commentary
    Adrian Warnock's UK Christian Blog
    (TBCMG) Writings on the Wall
    WannabeAnglican

    Orthodox Links
    OrthodoxyToday
    St, Stephen's Musings
    Dove and Pomegranates
    Philalethia
    Pensate Omnia

    Revolutions Around Cruciform Axis

    Catholic Links
    Mark Shea
    relapsed catholic
    Sursum Corda
    Fr. Rob Johansen: Thrown Back

    Amy Welborn's Open Book
    Lady in the Pew
    Southfarthing Soapbox
    Catholic Light
    David Warren Online


    General Interest Blogs
    Little Green Footballs
    Daimnation
    One Hand Clapping
    Reepicheep's Rant
    Andrew Hagen
    Pejmanesque
    Labarum Blog
    Achilles Running
    MarriageDebate.com

    Inspirational Links
    Daily Scripture Readings
    Saint of the Day
    Liturgy of the Hours
    Audio Liturgy of the Hours
    St. Augustine Day by Day
    Daily Meditation from Henri Nouwen
    Daily Meditation from Taize

    The Blogdom of God


    Alliance of Free Blogs

    Top Religion Blogs



    Greymatter Forums



    Valid RSS feed.

    © 2004 by Athanasius' alter ego