eibanner (73k image)

 

Home » Archives » August 2004 » One Missourian who needs to show me

[Previous entry: "Eden disrupted, and it's all our fault"] [Next entry: "Where's Monty Python when you need them?"]

08/05/2004: "One Missourian who needs to show me"


In the wake of Tuesday vote in Missouri to amend the state constitution to mandate one-man, one-woman marriage, some really loony reactions are being voiced in local newspapers. For instance, Rabbi Daniel Plotkin of the B'nai El Congregation in Frontenac wrote the following to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch:

As a new Missourian, I am disappointed in the passage of the same-gender marriage ban. This amendment is a blatant contradiction to the ideas of freedom and separation of church and state that this nation was founded upon.

It is unfortunate that one particular religious view (that of conservatives) is enshrined in the state constitution, and that clergy like myself, who believe that these marriages do deserve the sanction of God, are denied our right to act on our religious beliefs by giving these marriages the sanction of the state.


Let me get this straight: One-man, one-woman marriage, an idea that was universally accepted by religious and non-religious people alike for virtually the entire course of American history, is now a "particular religious view" supported only by conservatives. Furthermore--and here's where he really gets bizarre--it's a violation of the separation of church and state that he can't get state sanction for his religious belief that gay marriage is legitimate.

Please excuse me while I go check to see whether the sky is still blue.

Replies: 5 Comments

on Sunday, August 8th, WannabeAnglican said

No, you don't understand. It's a violation of separation of church and state only if you pass CONSERVATIVE laws.

Glad to be of help.

on Sunday, August 8th, The Rabbi said

The first comment I sent was censored by your right wing sight.Let me try again.GAY PEOPLE,JEWS,BLACKS,and all American People in this country are Gods children and deserve Human Dignity,respect,and the protections of the constitution.Do I get censored again for the truth?

on Sunday, August 8th, Christoher said

Rabbi,

I suggest that if you are going to speak the truth, you speak all of it. Do Christians, Jews, and others also get the dignity, respect, and protections of the constitution? If so, why establish your religion (which includes "gay marriage") in law?

on Sunday, August 8th, Christoher said

Rabbi,

I suggest that if you are going to speak the truth, you speak all of it. Do Christians, Jews, and others also get the dignity, respect, and protections of the constitution? If so, why establish your religion (which includes "gay marriage") in law?

on Monday, August 9th, Athanasius said

Rabbi: I have no idea what you're talking about re: censorship. I haven't censored anything. You are, from this point forward, however, banned from commenting. This is a "no trolls allowed" zone. Please go back to your porn site, if you're one of the sad souls who got referred here from there.

Home
Archives


"Great blog...and I love the title." Father Hans Jacobse, OrthodoxyToday

"Wisdom for the ages...Thomas Aquinas could learn from this guy." Glenn Reynolds

  • E-mail Me!





  • Blogroll Me!

    News Links
    Christianity Today
    First Things
    Touchstone
    Armavirumque: The New Criterion
    GetReligion
    The Weekly Standard
    NRO
    Jerusalem Post
    New York Times
    Washington Post

    Anglican/Protestant Links
    Classical Anglican Net News
    Institute on Religion and Democracy
    Midwest Conservative Journal
    Titusonenine
    Pontifications
    RatherNot Blog
    Stand Firm
    Whirlwind
    Imago Dei
    Blithering Idiot
    Wanderings of a Post-Modern Pilgrim
    Dunker Journal
    Evangelical Outpost
    Martin Roth Christian Commentary
    Adrian Warnock's UK Christian Blog
    (TBCMG) Writings on the Wall
    WannabeAnglican

    Orthodox Links
    OrthodoxyToday
    St, Stephen's Musings
    Dove and Pomegranates
    Philalethia
    Pensate Omnia

    Revolutions Around Cruciform Axis

    Catholic Links
    Mark Shea
    relapsed catholic
    Sursum Corda
    Fr. Rob Johansen: Thrown Back

    Amy Welborn's Open Book
    Lady in the Pew
    Southfarthing Soapbox
    Catholic Light
    David Warren Online


    General Interest Blogs
    Little Green Footballs
    Daimnation
    One Hand Clapping
    Reepicheep's Rant
    Andrew Hagen
    Pejmanesque
    Labarum Blog
    Achilles Running
    MarriageDebate.com

    Inspirational Links
    Daily Scripture Readings
    Saint of the Day
    Liturgy of the Hours
    Audio Liturgy of the Hours
    St. Augustine Day by Day
    Daily Meditation from Henri Nouwen
    Daily Meditation from Taize

    The Blogdom of God


    Top Religion Blogs



    The One Ring
    << # St. Blog's Parish ? >>

    Greymatter Forums



    Alliance of Free Blogs

    Valid XHTML 1.0!

    Powered By Greymatter



    Valid RSS feed.



    © 2004 by Athanasius' alter ego