eibanner (73k image)

 

Home » Archives » May 2004 » Abu Ghraib: another view

[Previous entry: "Take that, varmint!"] [Next entry: "Bang a gong! We are on!"]

05/08/2004: "Abu Ghraib: another view"


Think all Muslims, all Middle Easterners, or all Iraqis feel the same way about the photos from Abu Ghraib? Not so, according to the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, which interviewed some local Iraqi immigrants:

"It's a terrible thing and it adds more wood to the fire," said Hussein Al-Muhanna, who came to the United States in 1993. "(But) to me, it's not the issue I have to worry about. To me, the main issue is Iraq's future."

Imad al-Turfy, another Everett resident, shows no sympathy for the prisoners, saying their treatment paled when compared with the horrors inflicted under Saddam Hussein's regime.

"They raped our women. They killed our kids. So there's hatred between us, the people here, and the people in Iraq," he said, referring to the Shiite Muslims who emigrated and the Sunni Muslims who ruled Iraq under Saddam.

"Anything coming to them would make me happy."

Mosafer Al-Yaseri, a Lynnwood resident, said that the abuse by some soldiers should not taint the overall efforts of the U.S. Army.

"(The Iraqis) feel soldiers come from good families. Over there, there are 135,000 soldiers. Out of that, 10 people are bad," he said.


And as for Arab media showing the photos over and over again:

Mosifer Al-Yaseri said that while the Arab TV network al-Jazeera has repeatedly shown photos of the Iraqi prisoners, it did not report about abuses under Saddam.

"If there's a good story about how Iraq has changed, they never show it," he said. "They never showed a bad thing about Saddam Hussein."


This doesn't mitigate anyone's guilt, of course, nor is it meant to imply that Arab outrage is any less real. Just pointing out that things aren't as black-and-white as they seem.

Replies: 3 Comments

on Monday, May 10th, Little Fly said

Black and white or no, these tortures are extremely serious, and we have a responsibility to question how they could have happened. The administration already knows that domestic support of this operation hangs by a thread, and that internatitional support is even more tenuous. As horrible as Sadam was, there is no reson to believe that this conflict could not contribute to greater suffering in the future, both in and outside of Iraq. I hope Bush understands that discoveries like this may actually contribute to terror and death in places like Israel, Spain, and closer to home. If we do not take responsibility for the fact that our actions contribute to the terror against us, then we are truly blind.

on Monday, May 10th, Robert Jones said

Let's set the record straight. This was not torture. They were abused and humiliated. I agree it should not have happened, but it is nowhere near comparable to what went on in Iraq before, or to some of the things that happened during WW2 or the Vietnam War. I also agree the soldiers involved should be punished, but let's keep it in perspective.

on Monday, May 10th, Little Fly said

Okay, I don't care what you call. What you call it does not matter. What other people call it does.

Home
Archives


"Great blog...and I love the title." Father Hans Jacobse, OrthodoxyToday

"Wisdom for the ages...Thomas Aquinas could learn from this guy." Glenn Reynolds

  • E-mail Me!



  • Blogroll Me!

    News Links
    Christianity Today
    First Things
    Touchstone
    Armavirumque: The New Criterion
    GetReligion
    The Weekly Standard
    NRO
    Jerusalem Post
    New York Times
    Washington Post

    Anglican/Protestant Links
    Institute on Religion and Democracy

    Classical Anglican Net News
    Midwest Conservative Journal
    Titusonenine
    Pontifications
    Stand Firm
    Blithering Idiot
    Wanderings of a Post-Modern Pilgrim
    Dunker Journal
    Evangelical Outpost
    Martin Roth Christian Commentary
    Adrian Warnock's UK Christian Blog
    (TBCMG) Writings on the Wall
    WannabeAnglican

    Orthodox Links
    OrthodoxyToday
    St, Stephen's Musings
    Dove and Pomegranates
    Philalethia
    Pensate Omnia

    Revolutions Around Cruciform Axis

    Catholic Links
    Mark Shea
    relapsed catholic
    Sursum Corda
    Fr. Rob Johansen: Thrown Back

    Amy Welborn's Open Book
    Lady in the Pew
    Southfarthing Soapbox
    Catholic Light
    David Warren Online


    General Interest Blogs
    Little Green Footballs
    Daimnation
    Andrew Hagen
    Pejmanesque
    Labarum Blog
    Achilles Running
    MarriageDebate.com

    Inspirational Links
    Daily Scripture Readings
    Saint of the Day
    Liturgy of the Hours
    Audio Liturgy of the Hours
    St. Augustine Day by Day
    Daily Meditation from Henri Nouwen
    Daily Meditation from Taize

    The Blogdom of God


    Top Religion Blogs



    The One Ring
    << # St. Blog's Parish ? >>

    Greymatter Forums



    Alliance of Free Blogs

    Valid XHTML 1.0!

    Powered By Greymatter



    Valid RSS feed.



    © 2004 by Athanasius' alter ego